Home » 30 hours » Three solutions for childminders who fear losing business to the 30 hours problem

Three solutions for childminders who fear losing business to the 30 hours problem

Welcome to our blog

Follow to receive articles by email on all aspects of childminding best practice and stay up to date with important changes in legislation affecting childminders.

In September 2017, each childminder will have to decide for themselves whether to offer parents some or all of the 30 funded hours. With the new funding rates, some childminders will find themselves better off and that offering the 30 hours could even be a good business opportunity. But many childminders are worried that they will HAVE to offer funded hours, and at less than their current hourly rates, or risk losing business to nurseries and other childminders. The uncertainty of the hourly rate, poor communication from some local authorities and anxiety about planning ahead is making this a very stressful change for many childminders.


What should you do if you feel you HAVE to offer at least some of the funded hours? 

Not everyone feels they have a choice when it comes to offering the funded hours. Many childminders feel they will HAVE to offer the 30 hours or they will lose business to nurseries or other childminders who do. So if you are going to offer the 30 hours, here are three things you should consider:


 1. Look into how you can exploit the ‘top up loop hole’.

hobsons choice childminding service - childminding humourThe legislation is leaving a nice loop hole that you can and should exploit about “extra charges”. Many local authorities refuse to call them “top up charges”, but that is essentially what they are. For example, if you are currently charging £5 an hour and your local authority says it will pay you £4 an hour for funded children, then you should seriously consider charging parents £1 an hour directly for ‘activities, outings and food’ etc. so that you are not out of pocket. I’m sure with a bit of creativity you can work this loop hole to make sure you don’t end up worse off under the funding. You will have to be careful about how you phrase this because the extra charges are not supposed to be “compulsory” or “conditional on taking up the space”. But I do feel that these extra charges give you some flexibility around your hourly rate and could be applied creatively where needed.


2. Look into “blended care” and find a partner now

Lots of parents are expected to split their 30 hours between different carers, such as a pre-school and a childminder. The government thinks that lots of parents will want to do this, and it could be a good business opportunity for you if you grab it now. If you plan to offer “blended care”, then you should get in contact with your proposed partner as soon as possible. Check out some working models of how you might offer blended care on the 30 Hours Toolkit published by the Families and childcare Trust.

3. Consider putting your prices up on under 3s and after school care

While this sounds awful, it may be necessary and I know that some nurseries will make up the shortfall in their funding this way. Many nurseries charge more for baby rooms now because of the extra staff needed, so if nurseries will make up the funding shortfall by putting their prices up in their baby rooms, why shouldn’t childminders?  If you feel pushed into offering care at a lower rate than works for you, then this is certainly one option you could consider.


Approach this an opportunity not a threat

Really consider carefully whether you should do the funded places or not. Don’t just throw the idea out as impossible, or reluctantly take that pay cut and feel angry at the world. Make a business plan and work out how much this is likely to cost you (or benefit you) with realistic estimates of how many children you are likely to have on your books at any point in time.

It is also important that you talk to YOUR parents so you get a feeling for what they will be likely to do – will they stay with you even if they have to pay a “top up fee”, or will they run for the cheapest care option going?

The most important thing to remember over the next few months is to have the attitude that you are not going to let nurseries or other childminders steal your business. Don’t let yourself slip into the feeling of inevitability, that it is all somehow out of your control and the government is going to destroy your childminding business!  Every childminder is in a different situation so do be very careful not to pay too much attention to every horror story you read on Facebook which could be very different from what will be happening in your local authority. You can and will retain and even work all this change to your advantage, if you stay on top of the changes, plan ahead and keep a positive attitude.


Two articles from industry leaders with sensible 30 hours’ information

If you are worried about the introduction of the 30 hours – then have a read of these two articles which are the two best sources of sensible information I’ve read on the subject to date:

This article by Pacey will put your mind at ease about a lot of the rumours you might have heard, so read this, including the comments section.  It’s a good article and answers a lot of questions.

This article from Nursery World gives you information on the national funding formula minimum rate and what that means for childminders.

You might also want to read my blog about hourly rates and setting sensible pricing:


Childminding Best Practice Newsletter

Sign up for the free quarterly Childminding Best Practice Newsletter using the orange sign up box on my website and I will send you best practice ideas, childminding news, EYFS tips, outstanding ideas, stories from other childminders, arts and crafts project templates, new products, and links.



About Kay Woods and Kids To Go

Kay Woods Kids To GoKay Woods has been writing and selling childminding resources through her company Kids To Go since 2008. Her products include the Ultimate Childminding Checklist, the Learning Journey Plus for planning, observation and assessment and best practice resources promoting diversity, safety and childminding in the great outdoors (Forest Childcare). She is the author of the Start Learning book set published by Tarquin and she writes the free quarterly Childminding Best Practice Newsletter.

Lots of places offer help to childminders. I provide solutions.



  1. Sheila Dent says:

    Hi Kay Thanks for this. You have been more informative than our local authority. Keep up the good work🙂 Sheila

    On Tue, Jan 24, 2017 at 4:20 AM, Childminding Best Practice wrote:

    > Kay Woods posted: “In September 2017, each childminder will have to decide > for themselves whether to offer parents some or all of the 30 funded hours. > With the new funding rates, some childminders will find themselves better > off and that offering the 30 hours could even be ” >


  2. Carol says:

    Surely a childminder can charge what she wants so if she charges £5 an hour and the funding is only £4 an Hour then She wud charge £1 an hour £30 for 30 hours

    Sent from my iPhone



    • Kay Woods says:

      Hi Carol,
      You will have to be very careful about doing things that way. You can’t just charge people the extra amount. It has to be for something like activities or food. Follow the link in my article to that Pacey article which spells it out properly. You also can’t make it conditional on taking up the space. so you have to find a creative way to charge for that extra £1 an hour if you don’t want to be out of pocket, but without actually making it a price. I hope that wasn’t clear as mud. Please read through the Pacey article.


  3. roland says:

    you can refuse to offer funded hours 12-2pm and charge whatever you need to make up the shortfall


  4. Helen says:

    LOL =) I think you are forgetting heating and lighting and garden time!


  5. Emma smith says:

    Putting prices up for under 3’s and after school care, grossly unfair and very unprofessional of you to suggest it!


    • Kay Woods says:

      Hi Emma,
      I think that quite a lot of nurseries do this already. My girls’ nursery used to charge higher rates for babies because of the higher ratios. I don’t think it would be unprofessional to at least consider this as a solution to the problem of potentially losing business. It’s just a thought and if nurseries are doing it, then childminders should think about it too.


    • lisa says:

      I agree


  6. Lisa Tomlin says:

    I am horrified by your email. what you propose as extra charges is nothing short of exploitation!  I do agree with some additional charges for food etc as they can indeed be otional and provided by the parent if they so wish.  but toy/cot rental and nappy changing fees!! if patents choose not to pay for those??? and will you not provide drinking water if it is not paid for???  this makes childminders look very bad and I do not wish to be associated with your mailings any longer please remove me from your mailing list immediately.

    Sent from my Samsung device


    • Kay Woods says:

      Hi Lisa
      I’m sorry for the confusion. The photo was intended to be a joke and to make people laugh. You are certainly not the only person not to get that I was joking and I’m sorry about that. I had not intended to imply that childminders could ever charge extra for nappy changes and drinking water. sorry about that,
      If you want to unsubscribe there is a button at the bottom of the email where you can unsubscribe.


      • lisa says:

        it was a joke in very bad taste as this is sent out under the heading “best childminding practice” if your role is seen as advising on best practice then a “joke” like this has no place. the use of the word “exploit” is also very unprofessional and these charges if anyone takes them as suggestions would reflect very badly on how childminders provisions are perceived. I have unsubscribed. thankyou for your reply.


      • Kay Woods says:

        Thank you Lisa.


  7. Julie Walton says:

    How on earth can you charge for water and nappy changes. And toy hire?? If a parent opts out do we not give a drink or change a nappy and sit the child with no toys. That’s part of our job. Ridiculous.


    • Kay Woods says:

      Hi Julie,
      I’m sorry for the confusion. The photo was intended to be ridiculous and to make people laugh. You are certainly not the only person not to get that I was joking and I’m sorry about that. I had not intended to imply that childminders could ever charge extra for nappy changes and drinking water. sorry about that,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,259 other followers


Active learning Activities for childminders British values Challenge characteristics of effective learning childminder childminder food business legislation childminder food safety childminder fridge thermometers childminders with high expectations childminders working with parents childminding childminding activities Childminding best practice Childminding Best Practice Newsletter childminding British values childminding business advice childminding closing gaps childminding directories childminding food receipts childminding humour childminding inspection childminding outdoor spaces Childminding outings childminding posters childminding risk assessment childminding safety childminding self care COEL Communication with parents continual professional development for childminders creating and thinking critically cultural capital display ideas for childminders diversity awareness for childminders diversity planning for childminders early years inspection handbook EYFS filling childminding vacancies food allergens childminders Forest Childcare Forest Childcare Association inspection tips intent implementation impact January ladybird activity ladybird craft Learning Journeys learning walk loose parts marketing for childminders mathematics mathematics activity mathematics observations maths maths activity maths obsertvation news new to childminding next steps observation observations ofsted inspection Ofsted inspections British Values omicron Outdoor childminding partnership working planning posters for childminding settings safer food better business for childminders spider activity spider craft supporting learning at home using themes working in partnership with parents
%d bloggers like this: