Home » Characteristics of Effective Learning (COEL) » What is new for childminders in the Sept 2019 Inspection Framework?

What is new for childminders in the Sept 2019 Inspection Framework?

Welcome to our blog

Follow to receive articles by email on all aspects of childminding best practice and stay up to date with important changes in legislation affecting childminders.

Lots of childminders have been asking for a guide to the September 2019 Inspection Framework. I have done my best in this article to wade through the new Ofsted jargon and pull out what I think are the most important points for childminders.


The Common Inspection Framework has been replaced with the Education Inspection Framework (EIF)

From Sept 2019, the Common Inspection Framework will be replaced by a new document called the Education Inspection Framework (EIF). This document needs to be read in conjunction with the updated version of the Early Years Inspection Handbook.


Be familiar with the new judgement areas


One key change to the structure of the Inspection Handbook document is the judgement areas. What was previously two separate areas ‘Teaching, learning and assessment’ and ‘outcomes’ is now combined into one new category: ‘quality of education’. What was previously ‘personal development, behaviour and welfare’ is now split into ‘behaviour and attitudes’ and ‘personal development’. Leadership and management remains the same.


Know what ‘curriculum’ you offer

The word ‘curriculum’ is central to the new Framework, so you need to be familiar with the term. In the Early Years your ‘curriculum’ in an ‘education’ sense is defined by the EYFS Statutory Framework – it is the seven areas of learning and development.


Have an idea of HOW you offer the EYFS curriculum in your setting and why you do what you do

You should be able to explain to an inspector broadly HOW you teach the children the seven Areas of Learning in your setting. Most childminders use a combination of adult-led learning (structured activities) and free play. You will also need to show that whatever type of curriculum you offer promotes the Characteristics of Effective Learning (COEL) which are important for turning children into good lifelong learners in school. You should be able to explain to an Ofsted inspector your choices in terms of what types of activities you do in your setting and why.

“Learn, Know and Do” is Ofsted’s new phrase. You must be able to explain to the Ofsted inspector what you hope that the children should be able to learn, know and do as a result of the EYFS curriculum you offer.


Be familiar with the idea of: “Intent – Implementation – Impact” and how this relates to the ‘quality of education’ you offer

Across all seven areas of learning and development, when you plan anything for the children, you should have a purpose, your ‘intent’ for what the children should learn from what you are planning. You then ‘implement’ the activity by doing it. After you have finished the activity you should be able to evaluate the ‘impact’ that the activity had on the children’s learning and development.

An easy example might be getting out a jigsaw puzzle. Your ‘intent’ in planning a jigsaw activity is to promote early maths skills. Doing the jigsaw is how you are ‘implementing’ the idea of ‘promoting maths skills’. After you have finished doing the jigsaw you should ask yourself what ‘impact’ the activity had on the children. In other words, you should be able to identify what the children learned from the jigsaw activity and how you would build on the jigsaw with further maths activities.

A more complex example might be a child you have established as being poor at sharing toys. Your ‘intent’ is to find ways to help the child to become better at sharing. To ‘implement’ this, you decide to plan a series of craft activities over the next six months that will specifically require the child to share craft items in a safe, supervised setting where you can intervene when the child forgets to share. After six months it would be important to ask yourself what ‘impact’ these craft activities have had on the child’s learning in this area and see if what you have been doing has worked, or if you need to come up with a new plan.

This is really nothing different to what you have been doing already with the observation – assessment – planning cycle. But you need to be familiar with the new terms: ‘Intent – Implementation – Impact’ because the Ofsted inspector will use them at your inspection.

Let me also stress that you do not need to write any of this down if you don’t want to. As long as you are able to explain this to an Ofsted inspector and demonstrate how you are involving parents in your plans and making it clear what they should be doing at home to help their child, you don’t need to write it down if you don’t want to.

In summary, for every activity you plan:

  • Decide what the children you look after need to learn and develop (intent)
  • Deliver this so that the children make progress in the seven areas of learning (implementation)
  • Ask yourself how you will know if what you planned to deliver was successful? What can the children do now or know that they couldn’t before as a result of what you planned? (impact)


Think how you will tell your Ofsted inspector about how you teach children without showing them piles of ‘data’

Do not be surprised if your inspector no longer wants to look at your learning journeys or planning documents. They have been clear that they do not want to see a paperwork mountain. But if you are doing a ‘dinosaurs’ theme with the children when your inspector visits, for example, you should be able to explain out loud your ‘Intent’ of doing dinosaurs as a theme. In other words, what Areas of Learning and which COEL are you hoping to promote through studying this theme? She may also ask you how you are ‘Implementing’ your theme? You might be using dinosaur books, colouring pages, planning a day trip to the science centre, making a craft activity, and playing a dino-bones counting game. You should also be able to explain how you will measure what ‘impact’ the activities had on the children once you are finished.

I think that many childminders will find a quick written sketch of what you are planning and why will help you to stay focussed and be honest with yourself about what worked and what didn’t. Notes in the form of a written plan can help you to keep track of what you did so you can see what worked and what you’d want to change next time. But the key point Ofsted has stressed is that you should only do written planning if it is helpful to YOU. Your inspector will probably not look at it.


Plan your “Learning Walk” – your opportunity to show off what you do

When your inspector arrives in your setting, this is your opportunity to ‘wow’ them by taking them on a ‘learning walk’ (new Ofsted word) around your playroom and show them what you do. A learning walk relates specifically to education, so they don’t want a tour of your house, they want a tour of what you teach.

Suppose you have been studying dinosaurs (as in the example above) and you want your inspector to know this. One way would be to put up a display on your wall of your dinosaur theme activities – showing the children engaged in different activities that promote the different areas of learning. Another way would be to set up a “dig for dinosaur bones” invitation to play in your play tray and this would be a perfect activity for the children to be doing when your inspector arrives. She will see your display, your themed activity and later on you will sit down and read a Harry and the Dinosaurs book. Remember that you should be able to explain the learning goals of the activities you have planned within the theme, but you do not have to write this down if you prefer not to.  


Be familiar with the term ‘cultural capital’

All children come to your setting with different skills to each other. You need to be aware of a child’s strengths and weaknesses and plan activities to help address the weaknesses. How you plan your curriculum to enhance the opportunities you give to children especially the most disadvantaged is very important. I have written more about what cultural capital means to childminders in this article.


Be prepared for your inspector to want to question you while you do an activity at your inspection

This is not new but often takes people by surprise who have prepared folders of paperwork for their inspection that isn’t then needed. Your inspector may want to observe your children with you and discuss their learning, progress and behaviour as part of the activities the children are engaged in. She will then ASK you what the child learned and furthermore how you intend to build on the activity so that the child makes progress. She is more likely to do this than to ask to see your learning journeys. If you have assistants, you should be prepared for her to question them at the same level to prove you are training your staff properly.

Making learning journeys remains an important way to practice formally observing children and planning next steps for them. In my opinion it is also a nice way to share that information with parents. So please don’t throw your learning journeys into the bin!


If you want to show that you are offering good ‘quality of education’ you need to check that the curriculum you plan:

  • Is ambitious and sufficiently challenging
  • Includes everybody you childmind for including children with SEND
  • Increases the Cultural Capital of the children
  • Prepares children for being lifelong learners in school
  • Covers all seven areas of learning and development
  • Includes assessment of where the children are relative to the development milestones in Development Matters
  • Has a big focus on reading


‘Behaviour and attitudes’ and ‘personal development’ are things that help children’s life chances

The key points about these two judgement sections is that not much has really changed in terms of what Ofsted hopes to see you doing from what you did previously. They’ve split the sections up but haven’t really changed the content much.

You still need to be able to explain to the inspector how you help the children you look after to succeed in life and become good citizens of the future. Whereas the ‘quality of education’ focusses mainly on the learning and development areas of the EYFS, these two judgements focus more on the COEL plus welfare requirements of the EYFS like promoting healthy eating, physical exercise and self-care with a new emphasis on potty training. Make sure you are planning activities that actively promote the COEL and that you can recognise what these are when children display them.

The COEL really are more important than ever.


Be prepared for the inspector to actually want to speak to your parents at your inspection

Lastly I want to call your attention to a new section under how the inspector intends to ‘gather evidence’ at your inspection from talking to parents themselves. So do not be surprised if your inspector actually plans her visit around speaking to your parents!

Those are the key new points of new Education Inspection Framework and Early Years Inspection Handbook. You need to read these documents and make sure that you are following the new guidelines, especially if you are being inspected any time soon. From September onwards anything in this article is fair game!

Good luck!

Do you want to improve your understanding of the Characteristics of Effective Learning?

Promoting the Characteristics of Effective Learning PosterFor help putting the Characteristics of Effective Learning into practice including tools, activity ideas, certificates you can give to children, poster and display ideas, CPD worksheets for your setting, examples for your SEF and a setting checklist for the COEL, check out my new Characteristics of Effective Learning Pack for childminders.


About Kay Woods and Kids To Go

Kay Woods Kids To GoKay Woods has been writing and selling childminding resources through her company Kids To Go since 2008. Her products include the Ultimate Childminding Checklist, the Learning Journey Plus for planning, observation and assessment and best practice resources promoting diversity and childminding in the great outdoors (Forest Childcare). She is the author of the Start Learning book set published by Tarquin and she writes the free quarterly Childminding Best Practice Newsletter.

Lots of places offer help to childminders. I provide solutions.



  1. susan hirons says:

    Hi, Could you let me know what is expected from childminders that only have children before and after school and school holidays, thankyou Susan

    Sent from Outlook


Leave a Reply

Please follow Childminding Best Practice

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,243 other subscribers


30 hours funding accident prevention for childminders Active learning activities Activities for childminders Are sausages a healthy food for children Are sausages banned for childminders art projects British values burgers for children burgers for kids Can I give my childminded children sausages? Can I give my childminded kids sausages? Challenge characteristics of effective learning childminder childminder food business legislation childminder food safety childminder fridge thermometers childminder library priviledges childminders childminders and food childminders cutting costs childminders getting sick childminders healthy eating childminders with high expectations childminders working with parents childminding childminding activities Childminding and food Childminding best practice Childminding Best Practice Bumper Newsletter Childminding Best Practice Club Childminding Best Practice Newsletter childminding British values childminding business advice childminding closing gaps Childminding Competition childminding contract Childminding CPD Childminding Crafts childminding directories childminding food receipts childminding healthy eating childminding hourly rates childminding humour Childminding Ideas childminding inspection Childminding Inspection Tips Childminding in wild spaces childminding marketing Childminding outdoors childminding outdoor spaces Childminding outings childminding paperwork childminding pay childminding planning childminding posters childminding prices Childminding quiz childminding recipies childminding risk assessment Childminding Road Safety childminding safety childminding self care childminding stranger danger Christmas cards COEL Communication with parents Competition conjunctivitis advice for childminders continual professional development for childminders covid cpd for childminders creating and thinking critically cultural capital Development Matters diarrhoea and vomiting advice for childminders dinosaur burgers dinosaur sausages display ideas for childminders diversity awareness for childminders diversity planning for childminders diversity poster early years inspection handbook Early years planning Early Years science experiment Easter Basket Easter craft Essential Childminding Documents Essential Early Years Documents Evaluation schedule for inspections of registered early years provision Exclusion periods for childminders EYFS EYFS Art Projects EYFS Documents EYFS Fathers' Day Fathers' Day Fathers' Day Childminding Activity fear of failure feeling lonely childminder filling childminding vacancies first aid food allergens childminders Forest Childcare Forest Childcare Association Free Childminding Activity fun burgers for children fun burgers for kids fun sausages fun sausages for children fun sausages for kids guided self evaluation headlice advice for childminders Health and Safety Health and Safety Menu healthy burger recipe healthy burger recipe for children healthy burger recipe for kids healthy burgers for children healthy burgers for kids healthy children's sausage recipe healthy childrens burger recipe healthy childrens sausage recipe healthy cooking for children healthy cooking for kids healthy kid's burger recipe healthy kid's sausage recipe healthy kids burger recipe healthy kids sausage recipe healthy recipes for children healthy recipes kids healthy sausage recipe healthy sausage recipe for children healthy sausage recipe for kids healthy sausages healthy sausages for children healthy sausages for kids homework from my childminder hourly rate ideas inspection tips Integrated Review intent implementation impact January Kids To Go ladybird activity ladybird craft Learning Journeys learning walk long term planning loose parts low fat burger recipe low fat burgers low fat sausage recipe low fat sausages low salt burger recipe low salt burgers low salt sauages low salt sausage recipe marketing for childminders mathematics mathematics activity mathematics observations maths maths activity maths obsertvation National Childminders Day Nature Deficit Disorder never go anywhere with a stranger never take gifts from strangers New Childminders New childminders tips New Childminder Tips news newsletter new to childminding New To Childminding Tips next steps observation observations Official Childminding Documents ofsted inspection Ofsted inspections British Values Ofsted Inspection Tips Ofsted self evaluation form omicron Outdoor childminding parent questionnaires Parents Poster Partnership with Parents partnership working part time childminding planning planning checklist Playing and exploring poisonous garden plants poisonous plants on outings posters for childminding settings pre-school stranger danger pricing Progress Check Age 2 Quitting childminding recipes for childminders reduced fat burger recipe reduced fat burgers reduced fat sausage recipe reduced fat sausages reduced salt burger recipe reduced salt sausage recipe reduced salt sausages reducing childminding hours resilience training risk assessment for chidminding outings risk assessment for childminding garden Road safety Running your childminding business safer buildings safer food better business for childminders safer strangers Safety at Home Safety on Outings Safety Tips for childminders sausage recipe for childminders sausages for children sausages for kids Science activity SEF form SEF Model Answers Self-evaluation form tips self-reflective practice self evaluation short term planning spider activity spider craft star burgers star sausages Starting a childminding business Statutory framework for the EYFS staying healthy when you childmind STEM stranger danger supporting learning at home teaching childminded children to concentrate teaching stranger danger to pre-school children tips Updated COVID-19 policy for childminders February 2022 urban Forest Childcare using themes welcome poster for childminders What food can I give childminded children What food can I give childminded kids What foods can I give childminded children? What foods can I give childminded kids? what is a stranger What to do if you are worried that a child is being abused: Summary why can't childminders give children sauasges? Why can't childminders serve sausages Why can't I give my childminded children sausages? Why can't I give my childminding children sausages? Why can't I give my childminding kids sausages? working in partnership with parents working with parents
%d bloggers like this: